Latest Blog Posts
- The Triumph of Anaem Omot and the Menominee River CoalitionNestled along the serene banks of the Menominee River, the Anaem Omot area, also known as the Sixty Islands, stands as a symbol of resilience and… Read more: The Triumph of Anaem Omot and the Menominee River Coalition
- Fundraising TimeFundraising Time!Today, I am writing to ask you to support The Coalition to Save the Menominee River by donating any amount you can to help sustain… Read more: Fundraising Time
- Menominee River: A Vital Lifeline for Michigan and Wisconsin CommunitiesThe Menominee River: A Natural Treasure The Menominee River, a majestic waterway, forms the natural border between Michigan and Wisconsin. This river is not just a… Read more: Menominee River: A Vital Lifeline for Michigan and Wisconsin Communities
- Time for holiday cheer!We made it another year with No Back 40 Mine! The Coalition to Save the Menominee River will be having our annual Christmas Party on Saturday,… Read more: Time for holiday cheer!
- Fundraising Time!Today, I am writing to ask you to support The Coalition to Save the Menominee River by donating any amount you can to help sustain our… Read more: Fundraising Time!
- The Human Cost of Open-Pit MinesOpen-pit mines, also known as surface mines, are vast engineered excavations on the Earth’s surface. They are a common sight in mining for resources such as… Read more: The Human Cost of Open-Pit Mines
- The Ban on Open-Pit Mining: An Environmental ImperativeIn various regions around the globe, governments and environmental agencies have made the decisive move to ban open-pit mining, invoking a clarion call for environmental conservation.… Read more: The Ban on Open-Pit Mining: An Environmental Imperative
- The Environmental Toll of Open-Pit MiningOpen-pit mining, a practice integral to extracting essential minerals for modern life, stands at the forefront of environmental controversy. While the method is a mainstay for… Read more: The Environmental Toll of Open-Pit Mining
- Unearthing the Truth: The Environmental Risks of Open-Pit MiningIn the quest for mineral wealth, humanity has developed various methods of extracting valuable resources from the earth. Among these, open-pit mining stands out for both… Read more: Unearthing the Truth: The Environmental Risks of Open-Pit Mining
- Boneyard Road Walk** Please note: This is not a Coalition-sponsored event. The Coalition to Save the Menominee River is not liable for any actions. The directions to this… Read more: Boneyard Road Walk
- The Unbearable Cost of Sulfide Mining: A Planet Scarred ForeverLet’s get straight to the heart of the matter: there’s a saying that “there has never been a sulfide mine that does not pollute,” and it’s… Read more: The Unbearable Cost of Sulfide Mining: A Planet Scarred Forever
- Urge Your Michigan Lawmaker to Hold Polluters AccountableAttention: Michigan Supporters: The following was brought to us by one of our supporters. Please consider. Brief bill descriptions are below: SB 605 (Irwin) and HB… Read more: Urge Your Michigan Lawmaker to Hold Polluters Accountable
- The Clock is Ticking!This was in the Stephenson Journal last week. WE HAVE 30 DAYS. Keweenaw Land Association, Ltd, Of Ironwood, Michigan has requested direct, metallic mineral leases from the… Read more: The Clock is Ticking!
- Walking with our AncestorsN9596 River Road, Menominee, Michigan(5 miles north of Shakey Lakes to River Road) The event is sponsored by the Protectors of the Menominee RiverRespecting – Honoring… Read more: Walking with our Ancestors
- Protecting the Menominee River: A Call to ActionThe Menominee River, a natural wonder nestled in the heart of the Upper Peninsula, faces a pressing environmental threat – mining pollution. Fortunately, there is a… Read more: Protecting the Menominee River: A Call to Action
- The Unavoidable Consequence: Total PFOS AbandonmentIn the realm of environmental pollutants, PFOS (perfluorooctane sulfonate) stands out as a formidable adversary. Its stubborn persistence challenges conventional approaches to regulation and containment. In… Read more: The Unavoidable Consequence: Total PFOS Abandonment
- Sulfide Mining Environmental Regulations: Falling Short of Protecting Our PlanetIntroduction Sulfide mining, an extractive industry that has left a trail of environmental devastation in its wake, has faced regulatory scrutiny for decades. While some argue… Read more: Sulfide Mining Environmental Regulations: Falling Short of Protecting Our Planet
- Mining Pollution Concerns: Why Our Community Opposes a New MineIntroduction Our community has been a tight-knit, peaceful enclave for generations. Nestled amidst pristine landscapes, we have thrived on clean air, pure water, and fertile land.… Read more: Mining Pollution Concerns: Why Our Community Opposes a New Mine
- The Environmental Hazards of Heavy Metal Leaching from MinesIntroduction Mining has been a fundamental part of human civilization, providing valuable resources for various industries. However, the process of extracting these resources often comes at… Read more: The Environmental Hazards of Heavy Metal Leaching from Mines
- Reclamation Challenges of Sulfide Mining: A Sobering RealitySulfide mining, often touted for its economic benefits, leaves a lasting scar on the environment that demands our attention. In this article, we explore the formidable… Read more: Reclamation Challenges of Sulfide Mining: A Sobering Reality
Talk to land trust (conservation) people to buy up the land around the Menominee River. Explain that it is tax deductible to them. Click the button to read more about it and access the contact information.
Click the above link to read more about it. The DNR is providing an email address to get more detailed information on the direct leasing process. Email them by clicking the button below to let them know what you think.
This is what it is about:
Sadly, the proposed mineral leases are on state lands. The proposed lands are also in the vicinity of the Shakey Lakes County Park. The people of Menominee County continue to be overwhelmingly opposed to a metallic sulfide mine that would pollute any waterways, pose human health hazards from toxic metal contamination, and destroy the existing economy based upon tourism, recreation, and world-class fishing habitat. Now, in addition, there will be more truck traffic and heavy equipment. You, the DNR state that you promote “the public enjoyment of this state’s wildlife and other natural resources by providing public access to lands under the control of the department for outdoor recreation activities dependent on natural resources…” (Section 324.504 of the Natural Resources and Environmental Protection Act 451 of 1994).
If you were to grant this lease to Aquila/GORO, it would deprive the public of the clean air and water we rightly deserve. Metallic mining will release many pollutants into the air, waterways, and soil. The intended result is a metallic sulfide mine and leasing state-owned land for the purpose of developing a metallic sulfide mine is a violation of this public trust.
Furthermore, where is the oversight? An excellent example of the pollution threat and lack of oversight of local water supplies dates back to 2002, when Aquila Resources, the exploration company at that time, bored 769 drill holes, over 134,000 meters (83.3 miles) in Lake Township and Menominee County’s aquifer. Those test wells remain open and are not permanently capped. The failure to properly abandon these test holes creates a pollution risk to our drinking water. Now to add to the mix we have waste rock. The vast majority of the rock brought up is acid-draining waste. Where is this going? Into a tailings dam? A tailings dam is nothing, but an earthen structure destined to fail. This is a major environmental disaster just waiting to happen. I beg you to outlaw them.
Water is life. We cannot live without water. This alone should be sufficient reason to just say no!
Save the River! Saving the Menominee River to protect our water, air, soils, aquatic life, wildlife, and people from the dangers of open-pit metallic sulfide mining is very important! There has never been a safe sulfide mine!
We were featured on MLive!
Save the River Supporters
Thousands of supporters have donated time and/or money to our cause. This map has been updated on 2/7/2022. Only the first name and first letter of the last name have been added to the map. Also, no address, phone number, or email has been added as well. If you would like to join our supporter list just follow the link.
Working together to save the river, air, soils, aquatic life, wildlife, and people from the dangers of open-pit metallic sulfide mining.
Join us in our efforts to…
- Inform the public regarding the dangers of the mine.
- Seek donations for legal fees for Ted Warpinski, a renowned environmental attorney.
- Encourage local residents to get their well water tested.
Our mission is to work together to stop the Back Forty Mine.
The Menominee River was mentioned in the TV series, Das Boat. The entire episode is below. In the video below where it starts at 16:32, you can listen to when they mention our cause.
GOOD NEWS FOR OUR CAUSE!
Today American Rivers of Washington, D.C. announced that the Menominee River has been chosen as one of the Top Ten in their listing of “America’s Most Endangered Rivers of 2020!”
Menominee River named among America’s Most Endangered Rivers of 2020
Mining threatens cities’ water supplies and Menominee Tribe sacred sites
April 14, 2020
Shanyn Viars, American Rivers, (607) 426-8283, email@example.com
Dale and Lea Jane Burie, Coalition to SAVE the Menominee River (615) 512-3506, firstname.lastname@example.org
Dr. Al Gedicks, Wisconsin Resources Protection Council, (608) 784-4399, email@example.com
Allison Werner, River Alliance of WI, (608) 257-2424 x113, firstname.lastname@example.org
Washington, D.C. – For the second time in four years, American Rivers named the Menominee River among America’s Most Endangered Rivers®, citing the threat of a proposed metallic sulfide mine to drinking water supplies and sacred tribal sites. American Rivers and its partners called on Michigan’s Environment, Great Lakes and Energy (MEGLE) agency to deny the permit for this mining project and protect local communities and the cultural significance of the Menominee River.
“America’s Most Endangered Rivers is a call to action. This mine poses an unacceptable risk to the Menominee River and Lake Michigan,” said Shanyn Viars with American Rivers. “We cannot allow mine tailings to demolish Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin’s sacred sites or send toxic waste into drinking water supplies, potentially risking millions of people.”
A Canadian exploration company, Aquila Resources, Inc., seeks permits for a metallic sulfide mine on the banks of the Menominee River, near Stephenson, Michigan. Known as the Back Forty Project, the proposed mine and tailings dam would encompass 1,087 acres — the size of 1,435 football fields. If toxic acid mine drainage spilled out of the Back Forty tailings dam, it would send heavy metals linked to cancer, respiratory failure, and diseases of the nervous system, brain, heart, lungs, liver, and kidneys into ancient tribal ceremonial sites, the Menominee River and ultimately Lake Michigan. Currently, it is unclear if a contingency plan has been defined by MEGLE.
The Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin, the Coalition to SAVE the Menominee River, Inc., along with communities and other organizations in Wisconsin and Michigan, are fighting for their right to a clean river, joined in opposition to the exploration company, Aquila Resources, Inc. American Rivers also called on Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers and Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer to oppose this harmful project.
“After many years of metallic sulfide mining, with every mine proven to have polluted nearby water and contaminated the environment, we should recognize these ingredients as a recipe for disaster,” said Dale Burie, President, Coalition to SAVE the Menominee River, Inc.
“The potential for a catastrophic failure of Aquila’s proposed tailings dam threatens the Menominee River, the largest watershed in the Upper Peninsula, downstream Lake Michigan, and decades of clean water efforts. In addition, the sacred sites of Native Americans should be ‘no-go areas, protected from destructive mining projects,” said Al Gedicks, Executive Secretary, Wisconsin Resources Protection Council.
“The risks to our waters are too high for this project to go forward. It’s not a matter of if pollution will occur, it is a question of when it will occur. Long-term protection of drinking water, cultural resources, fisheries, and economies are far more important than this short-term project,” said Allison Werner, Policy and Advocacy Director, River Alliance of Wisconsin.
A world-class smallmouth bass fishery, the Menominee River supplies drinking water for 24,000 people in Marinette, Wisconsin, and Menominee, Michigan. Winding through sacred tribal lands, the river is especially meaningful to the Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin, whose 10,000 years of history, culture, and heritage began where the river spills into Lake Michigan. Today, the tribe plays an active role in land management and river stewardship.
The annual America’s Most Endangered Rivers report is a list of rivers at a crossroads, where key decisions in the coming months will determine the rivers’ fates. Over the years, the report has helped spur many successes including the removal of outdated dams, the protection of rivers with Wild and Scenic designations, and the prevention of harmful development and pollution.
Other rivers in the region listed as most endangered in past years include the Boundary Waters (2018), Mississippi River (2020, 2019), Kinnickinic River (2018), and the St. Louis River (2016).
AMERICA’S MOST ENDANGERED RIVERS®
#1 Upper Mississippi River (Illinois, Iowa, Missouri, Minnesota, Wisconsin)
Threat: Climate change, poor flood management
#2 Lower Missouri River (Missouri, Iowa, Nebraska, Kansas)
Threat: Climate change, poor flood management
#3 Big Sunflower River (Mississippi)
Threat: Yazoo pumps project
#4: Puyallup River (Washington)
Threat: Electron Dam
#5: South Fork Salmon River (Idaho)
Threat: Gold mine
#6: Menominee River (Michigan, Wisconsin)
Threat: Open-pit sulfide mining
#7: Rapid Creek (South Dakota)
Threat: Gold mining
#8: Okefenokee Swamp (Georgia, Florida)
Threat: Titanium mining
#9: Ocklawaha River (Florida)
Threat: Rodman Dam
#10: Lower Youghiogheny River (Pennsylvania)
Threat: Natural gas development
River of the Year: Delaware River (Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New York, Maryland)
Honored as a national success story for restoration and a model for equitable and innovative clean water solutions.
ABOUT AMERICAN RIVERS
American Rivers believes every community in our country should have clean water and a healthy river. Since 1973, we have been protecting wild rivers, restoring damaged rivers, and conserving clean water for people and nature. With headquarters in Washington, D.C., and offices across the country, we are the most effective river conservation organization in the United States, delivering solutions that will last for generations to come. Find your connections in the PDF of the press release.
When asked to point to a mine that has never polluted, Joe Maki of the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality (MDEQ) confessed, “I cannot.”
What is all the fuss about?
What is the Back Forty Mine?
The Back Forty Mine is a proposal by Aquila Resources, a Canadian mining company, to extract copper, gold, and zinc from a site in Stephenson, Michigan. They intend to create an open-pit metallic sulfide mine.
The mine is estimated to cover 83 acres and be 750 feet deep (that’s the depth of two Statues of Liberty). It would be located only 50 yards from the edge of the Menominee River, which flows into Lake Michigan.
What’s the big deal about a hole in the ground?
It is the process of extracting the ore that contaminates local waters and soils. It produces sulfuric acid (the same caustic substance used in car batteries). This sulfuric acid dissolves rock and leaches out toxic heavy metals. Though the mines are lined below a certain level, this acid and metal seep out along the pit walls into rivers and aquifers (well water).
Also, cyanide will be used on-site because of the low grade of the ore. Because it is highly poisonous, cyanide has been banned from many countries and states, including Wisconsin.
Any contamination at the headwaters of the Menominee River is going to affect people who depend upon the fishing industry or the tourism industry— or for that matter, the clean water downstream.
Al Gedicks, Executive Secretary, Wisconsin Resources Protection Council.
Has there ever been a safe sulfide mine?
No. The Flambeau Mine operated near Ladysmith, Wisconsin, in the 1990s. Some point to it as a success, but the evidence of environmental contamination is overwhelming.
Let’s compare the two projects:
|Size of the mine pit||32 acres|
Max depth: 225 ft
Max depth: 750 ft
|Ore production||1.9 million tons||12.5 million tons|
|Waste rock production||8.6 million tons||54 million tons|
|Tailings generated from on-site processing of ore||0|
There was no on-site processing of ore at Flambeau. It was all shipped to Canada for smelting.
|11.8 million tons over the seven-year life of mine|
|Use of an underground cutoff wall to impede groundwater flow between mine pit and neighboring river||Yes|
(the Flambeau Mine pit was 140 feet from the Flambeau River)
|Yes, BUT the top of the bedrock where the cut-off wall will be keyed in, is weathered, fractured, and permeable.|
|Environmental footprint||181 acres||865 acres|
(4.5 times the Flambeau Mine)
Read a detailed report by Dr. Al Gedicks, Executive Secretary of the Wisconsin Resources Protection Council.
How can I help save the river?
If you are a property owner near the proposed site, we recommend having your well water tested. This will provide a baseline should the mine succeed, and we later must prove the negative consequences to our freshwater supply. Get more information here.
Funds are necessary to educate the public, oppose the mine, and support legal fees. Please consider making a contribution today.
WE INVITE YOU TO ATTEND OUR MONTHLY MEETINGS
Since the Covid 19 Pandemic, we have also been conducting our monthly meetings using ZOOM for our virtual meetings on the computer. Simply send us your permission to email@example.com to enter your email address into the Coalition’s roster.
Or you can visit us on the first Thursday of each month at Our Saviors Church, 1600 University Ave, Marinette, WI at 6:00 pm CST.
You will be sent an invitation with the “Link” to join us at our monthly meetings. The notices and the agenda will be sent out prior to the meeting as we meet every 1st Thursday of the month at 6:00 pm. CST.
Thank you for being on our team !!
Dale Burie, Corporate Resource Officer
Coalition to SAVE the Menominee River, Inc.
Read a detailed report by Dr. Al Gedicks, Executive Secretary of the Wisconsin Resources Protection Council.